White Co BOE Votes To Retain Curriculum Following Public Concern On Book

The White County School Board will not remove a book from its curriculum after a heated discussion Thursday night.

The book Hatchet caused concern for a particular family when 4th grade students were assigned to read the book. Themes of suicide, premarital sex and violence sited.

The school board voted 4 to 2 in favor of keeping the book following a review from the school system’s book committee. School Board Member Sherrie Stone voted to remove the book.

“I personally would not want my nine-year-old or 10-year-old reading about suicide and premarital affairs and violence,” Stone said. “I am sure there has to be a better subject matter for a 10-year-old.”

School Board member Diane Haston supported the book as a point of study. Haston said she believes teachers safely explore the themes of survival and healing.

“I don’t have a problem with this book,” Haston said. “This is a state approved book. Every kid, every student and every teacher that I spoke with loved the book.”

The book committee recommended retaining the book but did have issue with how the school system supported the family. The committee suggested offering equal alternatives for students to read that keep the same educational value.

School Board Chair Bob Young said the school board should trust the committee for its decision. The independent body is appointed by the school librarian and includes parents. It does not include school administration.

“They’re challenged to have to teach around difficult and challenging subjects,” Young said. “They do that in a professional way being aware of their audience, the text and ultimately the goal of what they are trying to address. I appreciate the committee for that.”

School Board Member Dewayne Howard voted for removing the book. Members Adam Hickey and Kenneth Robinson voted to keep the book.